Skip to content
Start here
Browse by category
AI Assistants5Accounting Software3Agency & Funnel Software4B2B Sales Outreach5Business Backup3Business Email & Office3CRM Platforms7Cloud Storage4Customer Support3Design Tools3E-Signature3E-commerce Platforms3Email Marketing1Inventory Management3Knowledge Management3Marketing Automation11POS Systems3Paid Ads Management3Password Managers3Payment Processing3Payroll & HR3Project Management7SEO Software3Sales Intelligence3Scheduling Software3Social Media Management3Team Communication1Time Tracking3Video Conferencing5Website Builders3Workflow Automation3
All categories →
Not sure what you need? Start hereTell us the job and see the software it takes, with verified prices for your team.
Recently verified
Decision brief builderTurn your shortlist into a one-page case for sign-off: verified prices for your team size, requirements and sources.
Recently updated switching guides
All 264 migration guides →
What every guide covers
What transfers, and what doesn’tThe vendor’s own import path, step by step, plus the data you will rebuild by hand. Switching cost estimatorAn adjustable estimate of the hidden labor, cleanup and retraining cost, with its assumptions shown.
Open data
Open data hub: every dataset (JSON/CSV)JSON and CSV under CC BY 4.0. Every value carries its source page and verification date. How we verify pricingThe research method behind every figure on the site.
Pricing data
Software IndexEvery tool we track in one sortable table: entry price, free plan, AI pricing and source. AI Pricing DatabaseHow each vendor bills its AI features: bundled, add-on, metered or quote. Stack Cost CheckerPrice every tool you pay for at list price, saved in a link that re-prices later.Black Friday Software DealsVerified deals plus the discounts you can get today, checked on each vendor’s site.
Original research
The B2B SaaS Sticker Shock IndexCheapest published entry price in 18 categories, ranked.2026 SaaS Price IncreasesEvery list-price increase we could verify, with old price, new price and source.The AI TaxHow 19 AI features are actually billed: bundled, add-on or metered.The Real Cost of a 10-Person Startup StackThree software stacks priced at published entry prices.
Security & compliance
Security & compliance databaseSOC 2, ISO 27001, HIPAA BAAs, and the plan you need for SSO, SCIM and audit logs. How to read security claimsSOC 2 vs ISO 27001, the single sign-on tax, and what “Not published” means.
Where your team works
Offline access databaseWhich tools work without internet, in which app, and what syncs later. Remote vs office guideIP allowlisting, device controls, data residency and office hardware, tool by tool.
Side by side
Security in every comparisonEach head-to-head now compares compliance, sign-in, offline and remote controls. Download the dataJSON and CSV, CC BY 4.0. Every value carries the vendor URL and quote.
Payment Processing

Square vs PayPal: Which Payment Processor Fits Your Business in 2026?

Square’s no-subscription online rate is lower than PayPal Checkout’s, and Square adds its own POS hardware for in-person sales. PayPal’s advantage is the buyer-side brand recognition of its wallet, which some shoppers trust and prefer at checkout.

By Bill Belcamino · Last updated September 23, 2026 · Our methodologyResearched and fact-checked by the HelpCompare team
Square logo3.3% + 30¢ per online transaction (Free plan, no monthly fee)

Square

VS
PayPal logo3.49% + 49¢ (PayPal Checkout)

PayPal

Run the cost calculator Compare pricing tiers
Square vs PayPalVerified Sep 23, 2026
Bill Belcamino
Bottom line up frontby Bill Belcamino, founder of HelpCompare
Editorial assessment

Bottom line up front: Is Square or PayPal the cheaper way to take payments online?

Square, on both parts of the fee: 3.3% + 30¢ online with no subscription, against PayPal Checkout's 3.49% + 49¢.

The fixed fee is the part to watch. On a small order that 49¢ weighs far more than the percentage gap, so a shop selling low-ticket items feels the difference on every sale, while a high-ticket seller mostly doesn't. PayPal's case is the buyer, not the rate: some shoppers trust its button and would rather not type card details into an unfamiliar site. Square also sells its own POS hardware, with in-person rates of 2.4 to 2.6% + 15¢. My rule: price your typical order at both fees, and if the PayPal button lifts checkout conversion enough to cover the gap, offer it alongside Square instead of picking one.

My read of the verified data on this page, checked against vendor sources on September 23, 2026. Disagree or spot an error? Tell Bill

Verified data

Square vs PayPal: quick facts

At a glanceSquarePayPal
CategoryPayment Processing
Entry price3.3% + 30¢ per online transaction (Free plan, no monthly fee)3.49% + 49¢ (PayPal Checkout)
Free planNo monthly subscription fee — pay only per-transaction processing feesNo monthly subscription fee — pay only per-transaction processing fees

Is Square cheaper than PayPal?

Square, on both the percentage and fixed fee: 3.3% + 30¢ against PayPal Checkout’s 3.49% + 49¢. This calculator applies each vendor’s percentage rate to your monthly volume; it does not add the fixed per-transaction fee (30¢ for Stripe and Square, 49¢ for PayPal), since that depends on your transaction count, not volume alone — add roughly (fixed fee × number of transactions) to each total for a fuller estimate.

Verified data

Square vs PayPal at a glance

CategorySquarePayPal
Online rate3.3% + 30¢ (no subscription)3.49% + 49¢ (PayPal Checkout)
In-person rate2.4–2.6% + 15¢Available via PayPal Zettle hardware, rates vary
Monthly feeNone requiredNone required
Buyer-side brand recognitionLower than PayPal’s walletVery high — widely recognized checkout button
POS hardware soldYes, nativelyVia PayPal Zettle, a separate product line
Built forUnified online + in-person + POSOnline checkout, especially where buyer trust in the brand matters

Verified September 23, 2026Prices recorded from each vendor’s own pricing page. See sources

Rates in USD from squareup.com/us/en/payments/our-fees and paypal.com/us/business/pricing, both checked September 23, 2026.

Editorial assessment

How they actually differ

Both processors let a customer pay online without a monthly subscription, but the fee structure and the buyer-side experience differ.

Rate comparison

Square’s standard online rate beats PayPal Checkout’s on both parts of the fee: a lower percentage (3.3% vs 3.49%) and a lower fixed fee (30¢ vs 49¢). This calculator applies each vendor’s percentage rate to your monthly volume; it does not add the fixed per-transaction fee (30¢ for Stripe and Square, 49¢ for PayPal), since that depends on your transaction count, not volume alone — add roughly (fixed fee × number of transactions) to each total for a fuller estimate.

What the buyer sees

PayPal’s recognizable wallet and “Pay with PayPal” button is a real conversion factor for some shoppers, who trust it or prefer not to enter card details on an unfamiliar site. Square’s checkout does not carry the same buyer-side brand recognition, even though its underlying rate is lower.

Moving between them

None of the three “imports” a merchant account from another — payment processing is tied to your bank relationship and underwriting with each provider, so switching means setting up a new merchant account, re-embedding new checkout code or buttons on your site, and running both providers in parallel briefly to confirm the new one settles correctly before fully cutting over.

Editorial assessment

Pros & cons

Square

Pros

  • Lower online rate on both percentage and fixed fee
  • Sells its own POS hardware for in-person sales
  • One account for online, in-person and phone payments
  • Lower in-person rate than online

Cons

  • Less buyer-side brand recognition than PayPal
  • No dedicated digital wallet with PayPal’s reach
  • Manual-entry rate (3.5% + 15¢) is on the higher side

PayPal

Pros

  • Widely recognized checkout button and wallet
  • Some shoppers actively prefer or trust PayPal at checkout
  • In-person hardware available via PayPal Zettle
  • No monthly fee required for standard Checkout

Cons

  • Higher rate than Square on both percentage and fixed fee
  • In-person hardware is a separate product line (Zettle), not as unified as Square
  • Rate advantage depends on buyer conversion lift outweighing the fee gap
Verified data

Cost calculator: what does your team actually pay?

Square

 
$0/mo

PayPal

 
$0/mo
 

Rates checked September 23, 2026. This calculator applies each vendor’s percentage rate to your monthly volume; it does not add the fixed per-transaction fee (30¢ for Stripe and Square, 49¢ for PayPal), since that depends on your transaction count, not volume alone — add roughly (fixed fee × number of transactions) to each total for a fuller estimate.

Choose Square if…

You want the lower processing rate and unified online/in-person/POS hardware under one account.

Choose PayPal if…

Buyer-side trust and recognition at checkout matters for your conversion rate, and you’re willing to pay a slightly higher rate for it.

Total cost over time

Uses your selections above. Estimate excludes add-ons, overages, and negotiated discounts.

Ready to pick your payment processor?

Neither requires a monthly commitment to start. If you sell online, A/B test offering both checkout options and see which converts better for your actual customers.

See Square pricing See PayPal pricing
Verified data

PayPal vs Square: security, offline & remote work

How PayPal and Square compare on compliance reports, sign-in controls, offline access and the setup details that matter for remote, hybrid and in-office teams. Every value links to the vendor page it came from.

What we checkedPayPalSquare
Security & compliance
SOC 2 reportNot publishedNot published
ISO/IEC 27001Not publishedCertifiedsource
Other certificationsPCI DSS Level 1 (Service Provider)sourcePCI DSS Level 1source
HIPAA (BAA)Not publishedNot published
GDPR data processing agreementDPA offeredsourceNot published
Single sign-on (SAML/OIDC)Not publishedNot published
SCIM user provisioningNot publishedNot published
Two-factor authenticationYessourceYessource
Admin audit logNot publishedNot published
Data residency choicesNot publishedNot published
EncryptionNot publishedCard-present payments encrypted end to end; no unencrypted payment data touches the devicesource
Self-hosting optionNot publishedNot published
Offline access
Offline modePartialOffline card payments work only on a PayPal Reader used through a third-party POS app built on the Zettle SDK; queued payments upload when the device reconnects.sourcePartialSquare POS apps on supported Square hardware can take cash and card payments offline; payments are stored in the app and process automatically on reconnection (ideally within 24 hours, expiring after 72 hours), while online orders, gift cards, Tap to Pay and manual card entry are unavailable offline.source
Desktop appsNot publishedNot published
Mobile appsiOS, AndroidsourceiOS, Androidsource
Offline limitsReconnect within 24 hours of the first offline payment; offline mode requires a PayPal Reader on the latest softwaresourceUpload within 24 hours, no later than 72 hours; not supported on Square Reader 1st gen v1/v2, Kiosk, Tap to Pay, manually entered cards, gift cards, Afterpay, Cash App Pay, Invoices app or services mode.source
Remote, hybrid & in-office
IP allowlistingNot publishedNot published
Device & session controlsNot publishedYesRemote device management: device profiles and codes, printer profiles, monitoring from off-site.source
Office & room hardwarePayPal sells the Bluetooth Card Reader and the PayPal Reader for in-person chip, contactless and mobile-wallet payments through the Point of Sale app.sourceSquare sells its own POS hardware: Reader for contactless and chip ($59), Terminal ($299), Handheld ($399), Stand ($149), Kiosk ($149) and Register ($899).source
Editorial assessment

What this means for your team

  • Audit reports: Square holds ISO/IEC 27001; we found no SOC 2 statement on either vendor’s site.
  • Working offline: PayPal and Square work offline only in part. Details are in the Offline mode row above.
  • In the office: PayPal: PayPal sells the Bluetooth Card Reader and the PayPal Reader for in-person chip, contactless and mobile-wallet payments through the Point of Sale app. Square: Square sells its own POS hardware: Reader for contactless and chip ($59), Terminal ($299), Handheld ($399), Stand ($149), Kiosk ($149) and Register ($899).

PayPal: worth knowing

  • RemoteA business account owner can add users and choose each user's account privileges from Account Settings. source
  • OfflineUninstalling the POS app, clearing the device cache or factory-resetting it while offline payments are pending permanently deletes those stored payments. source

Square: worth knowing

  • OfflineOffline payments not uploaded within 72 hours expire; Square recommends reconnecting within 24 hours. source
  • OfficeOffline payments will be enabled on all devices automatically unless the seller opts out (change rolled out March–April 2026). source
  • RemotePhone support is 6am–6pm PT on weekdays for Square Plus (first 90 days only on Square Free); only Square Premium includes 24/7 phone support. source
  • SecuritySquare is the merchant of record and maintains PCI certification, so sellers do not validate PCI compliance individually. source

Checked September 19, 2026 against each vendor’s own trust center, help docs and app pages. Hover or tap “source” to see the exact wording we relied on. “Not published” means we could not find the vendor saying it on its own site; it doesn’t mean the feature is missing. Plan names are the lowest plan the vendor says includes the feature. Security · Offline · Remote vs office · Download the data

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Square cheaper than PayPal?

Yes, on both the percentage and fixed fee: 3.3% + 30¢ against PayPal Checkout’s 3.49% + 49¢. Rates checked September 23, 2026.

Does PayPal have better buyer-side conversion?

Many shoppers recognize and trust the PayPal button specifically, which can offset its higher fee for some online sellers — this isn’t something HelpCompare’s pricing record can quantify for your specific store.

Does Square sell POS hardware like PayPal Zettle?

Yes, natively, and more centrally to its product than PayPal, which sells in-person hardware through its separate Zettle line.

Do either charge a monthly fee?

Not required for either — both offer no-subscription, pure per-transaction pricing.

Migration Guides

Already decided? Here’s how to actually switch.

Step-by-step migration guides covering what transfers automatically, what doesn’t, and how to handle the gap — in both directions.

Switching from Square to PayPal Switching from PayPal to Square
Editorial assessment

When to Buy — and When to Walk Away

Every “best payment processor” listicle tells you why to buy. Here’s the other half: the specific conditions under which Square or PayPal is the wrong purchase for your team.

Square

Buy Square if:

  • You want the lower processing rate
  • You want unified online, in-person and POS hardware
  • Buyer recognition of the PayPal brand isn’t a major factor for your store

Do NOT buy Square if:

  • Your buyers specifically look for or trust the PayPal button
  • You want a widely recognized digital wallet option
  • Conversion-rate lift from brand trust outweighs a fee difference for you

PayPal

Buy PayPal if:

  • Buyer-side trust and brand recognition at checkout matters
  • Your customers specifically want to pay with PayPal
  • You’re willing to pay a slightly higher rate for that trust

Do NOT buy PayPal if:

  • You want the lowest possible processing rate
  • You want fully unified in-person POS hardware, not a separate product line
  • Every fraction of a percent matters at your transaction volume

Canonical data for the tools on this page

Every pricing fact, rating, AI billing model and switching guide we hold on each tool, on one page, with the date each figure was last verified.

SquarePricing, free plan, AI cost & every comparison›PayPalPricing, free plan, AI cost & every comparison›
Square vs StripeHead-to-head comparisonSquare vs CloverHead-to-head comparisonSquare vs Shopify POSHead-to-head comparisonStripe vs PayPalHead-to-head comparisonPolar vs StripeHead-to-head comparison

Sources

Prices on this page were recorded from each vendor’s own pricing page on the date shown at the top of the page. Vendors change pricing often — check the live source before you buy.

Every figure is also in our open dataset (JSON and CSV, CC BY 4.0), with its source page and verification date. See how we research pricing.

Cite this page: HelpCompare, “Square vs PayPal”, helpcompare.com/square-vs-paypal/ (updated ).

Source links on this site are checked every month; last check . How sources are checked.

Start with the job

Guides for the jobs this software does

Plain-language guides: the steps, what to check before you buy, common mistakes, and every tool it takes with verified prices.

Take card paymentsAccept payments onlineSell onlineSell in person with a POSSend invoices and get paidPay bills and vendors on timeLet clients book appointments onlineAll 50 job guides
Need sign-off?

Turn this into a one-page decision brief

Verified prices costed for your team size, a check against your must-have requirements, the questions to settle before you sign, and a source for every figure. Print it, or paste it into an email to whoever approves the spend.

Build a decision brief

From shortlist to switched

Built for the leader who owns the selection, answers for the spend, drives the rollout, and lives with the results. HelpCompare covers the whole decision, not just the first step.

01 · CompareWhich tool fits your team, side by side.133 comparisons 02 · Price & approveSourced, dated pricing and a one-page brief for sign-off.Decision brief 03 · SwitchWhat moves, what you rebuild, what it costs.264 guides 04 · ShareDownload and cite the data. CC BY 4.0.Open data
Bill Belcamino, founder of HelpCompare
About the author

Bill Belcamino

Founder and author, HelpCompare

Engineer by training, operator by experience, marketer by choice. Bill spent eight and a half years as an engineer at HP, was COO of Auctiva (the number one third-party selling platform on eBay, past 200,000 users) and ran Google’s $70M/year search syndication partnership at Alot.com. Then he spent 13 years building his own web properties with his own money at stake. He has bought, trialled, integrated and cancelled more SaaS tools than he can count, and started HelpCompare because the real cost of switching tools is the part nobody covers.

“I’ve sat on both sides of the table: the agency recommending the tool and the client paying for it.”

Researched and fact-checked by the HelpCompare team. Pricing on this page was last verified on September 23, 2026. No paid sponsorships, no affiliate commissions.

Read Bill’s story How we verify pricingSpot an error? Tell Bill